You buy a New York co-op apartment, only to discover the building needs major repairs or has substantial debt. Soon, you are paying unexpected assessments, or extra fees charged to co-op owners, along with higher monthly maintenance costs. If your lawyer overlooked financial warning signs before closing, you may have grounds for a legal malpractice claim.
What financial problems should a co-op review uncover?
The New York attorney general identifies key records that can help reveal costly problems before you buy a co-op apartment. Depending on the transaction and your lawyer’s responsibilities, this review may include:
- Financial statements: Reports showing the co-op’s income, expenses and outstanding debts.
- Underlying mortgage: The mortgage on the entire co-op building and its upcoming payments.
- Reserve funds: Money available for major repairs and unexpected expenses.
- Board meeting minutes: Records discussing planned repairs, assessments or maintenance increases.
Missing important details in these records could leave you unaware of costly problems before closing.
When can missed warning signs become malpractice?
Discovering financial problems after closing does not automatically mean your lawyer committed malpractice. Under New York law, you must generally show that your lawyer failed to meet the skill and care expected of lawyers. You must also prove that the mistake caused you financial harm.
For example, board minutes might reveal a planned $2 million roof repair. If your lawyer missed this warning, you may need to show that the oversight caused you to pay more for the apartment than you otherwise would have.
Understanding whether your losses resulted from negligence
Unexpected co-op expenses do not necessarily mean your lawyer was negligent. However, your purchase contract, financial records and emails with your former lawyer may help establish whether important information was overlooked.
In New York, you generally have three years from when the lawyer made the alleged mistake, not when you discovered it, to file a claim. This deadline may be extended if your lawyer continued to handle the same matter. A legal malpractice attorney can review your case to see if your former lawyer made a costly mistake that may support a claim.
